Delivery or takeout! This is my second review. Once I placed my order on line, they called me just to double check...they had everything correct. When you are paying a premium for fine dining, you expect a certain level of service and this was not their night... I'm guessing it was a miscommunication and we weren't upset, but it did make us laugh. Find Old Homestead Steakhouse at 1 Borgata Way, Atlantic City, NJ 8401: Get the latest Old Homestead Steakhouse menu and prices, along with the restaurant's location, phone number and business hours. However, my friend who lives 4 hours away has talked about the prime rib since the last time he was here. Spinach Salad | Granny Smith Apples, Texas Pecans, Feta, Maple Cider Vinaigrette. All Rights Reserved. Old Homestead Steakhouse - Atlantic City The iconic steakhouse known as Old Homestead--which has been around since 1868--opened its first outpost in the Borgata Hotel Casino & Spa. The service is normally over the top good. I'll just start with the good stuff. Sliced White Turkey Breast | Apple, Poppy and Calvados Stuffing, French Green Beans Almondine, Mashed Sweet Potatoes and Marshmallows, Cranberry Sauce and Giblet Gravy . Full Old Homestead Steakhouse restaurant menu for location 1 Borgata Way Atlantic City, NJ 08401. This time, they were both again cooked perfectly. My husband and I were there for an Anniversary dinner. The Old Homestead Steakhouse has been an icon of New York City dining since 1868. Menu. Combing tradition and elegance, The Old Homestead Steakhouse has been serving the finest cuts of beef in New York City for over a century. With their second location in Atlantic City, guests can experience their trademarked domestically raised, hand-massaged Wagyu beef on both sides of the river. The food was ok. But at those prices, we probably wouldn't return based on the food we got.More. Menu; Old Homestead Steakhouse. My moms burger was so think that it was char burnt on the bottom to the point she had the slice off the bottom of the burger that was not edible. Ordered med and when I sliced into it was med-well at best. Check out the menu for Old Homestead Steakhouse.The menu includes gluten free menu, main menu, and wine menu. For the price, we were expecting a little more. Old Homestead: Steak House Borgata! Are sandals allowed for women? The food was ok. First Course. Originally founded in 1868 in NYC, Old Homestead is one of the longest continually serving restaurants in America. What is the dress code, is a jacket required for men? We have had better meals at both Bobby Flays & Wolfgang's.... 585 reviews of Old Homestead Steak House "This is one of those reviews were you just don't know how many stars to give the place. The family opened up the Borgata location and the food is of the same amazing quality. Nice job on keeping up your standards during these crazy times. We did find it funny when we were asked if we wanted fresh pepper and then were handed a shaker. The arrival of an outpost of New York's 144-year-old Old Homestead Steakhouse at Caesars Palace joins the two while simultaneously taking steakhouse … more. It has been around for 200 years serving the best meats and seafood in New york. Like the original in NYC and its new baby brother in Vegas, Old Homestead takes a proven product and reproduces it flawlessly at the Borgata. Check out the menu for Old Homestead Steakhouse.The menu includes gluten free menu, main menu, and wine menu. Unfortunately, my dinner on Christmas Eve fell short. The other couple had a Caesar salad which they really liked. I will see go back cause I enjoy dining here when they get it right, this was not that time!!! ... old homestead @borgata atlantic city • old homestead borgata atlantic city • old homestead steak house atlantic city • old homestead steak house at borgata atlantic city • old homestead steakhouse atlantic city • was exceptional as we were taken very good care of by staff. The salmon & lamb looked delicious but don’t stray from these items because everything else was subpar: salads, fish.More. Old Homestead has always been higher on my personal list of steakhouses so I was really excited to dine there recently. For detailed hours of operation, please contact the store directly. This has happened before here and did not have the wait time for a new entree so I just ate my mw steak. The restaurant is very nice, we sat upstairs and the ambiance is romantic. Things Better Not Stored in Freezer: I Wish I'd Known It Earlier. Steak houses are a must visit when we travel for special occasions. tempura battered, pickled cucumber, chipotle mayo, anaheim pepper puree, romaine, radicchio, tomatoes, gherkins, chopped egg, apple wood bacon, shaved reggiano, onion crunch, thousand island, crumbled blue cheese dressing, apple wood bacon, fresh basil, extra virgin olive oil, aged balsamic vinegar, mixed greens, salami, hearts of palm, chick peas, artichoke, red onion, cherry tomato, peppers, blue cheese, bacon, champagne basil mustard dressing, Applewood Smoked Bacon Wrapped 10 Oz. Hotels near Harrah's Atlantic City Casino, Hotels near Atlantic City Aquarium Historic Gardner's Basin, Hotels near (ACY) Atlantic City Intl Airport, American Restaurants for Breakfast in Atlantic City, Mexican Restaurants for Families in Atlantic City, Seafood Restaurants for Special Occasions in Atlantic City, Best Udon & Soba (Wheat & Buckwheat Noodle) in Atlantic City, Food Delivery Restaurants in Atlantic City, Kid Friendly Restaurants in Atlantic City, Restaurants for Group Dining in Atlantic City, Restaurants for Special Occasions in Atlantic City. they had everything correct. Nothing like the last time.More, This is the version of our website addressed to speakers of English in the United States. We had the Steakhouse Salad. The Old Homestead, a New York City institution, is one of the country’s oldest steakhouses and is known for serving the finest steaks in the Big Apple for nearly 150 years. Nothing was fantastic or over the top, the food was mediocre at best. Old Homestead, Atlantic City: See 767 unbiased reviews of Old Homestead, rated 4 of 5 on Tripadvisor and ranked #21 of 324 restaurants in Atlantic City. Not coming back.More, Dined here for my birthday dinner in November. Get quick answers from Old Homestead staff and past visitors. Also see photos and tips from visitors. Surf and turf in our room was even better than I thought it would be!!! The salad was good very good, Crisp greeens with flavorful dressing. Hours may fluctuate. The Old Homestead didn't live up to their name or reputation. From Raw bar, Salads, Pasta to Steaks & Chops, Seafood we serve the finest. Welcome to Old Homestead Steakhouse. we had the fried calamari which was light, crunchy, and tasted great. From OUR personal viewpoint, Old Homestead Steakhouse inside the Borgata Casino at One Borgata Place in Atlantic City, NJ is ALWAYS OUR surprising and amazingly-pleasurable VERY -HIGH-END Eatery we enjoy each time we select this eatery whenever we go in for Supper. See the classic The Old Homestead Steakhouse menus. Had reservations and had to wait to be seated for 20-25min. Order Online Tickets Tickets See Availability Directions {{::location.tagLine.value.text}} Sponsored Topics. Latest reviews, photos and ratings for Old Homestead Steak House at 1 Borgata Way in Atlantic City - view the menu, ⏰hours, ☎️phone number, ☝address and map. no not at all. We do love this restaurant but everything is a la carte and very pricey but good, 1 Borgata Way, Atlantic City, NJ 08401-1946. that assisted us were friendly and timely. OLD HOMESTEAD SMOKEHOUSE BBQ. The service and the food was incredible! Also see photos and tips from visitors. Old Homestead Steakhouse さんの メニュー をチェックする。The menu includes gluten free menu, main menu, and wine menu. Old Homestead Steakhouse; Menu; Old Homestead Steakhouse 1 Borgata Way, Atlantic City, NJ 08401 (609) 317-1000 View Business Details. Dundee Valley, Oregon, 2012 When you are paying a premium for fine dining, you expect a certain level of service and this was not their night... If you would like to investigate further on pricing around all menu items, YP.com has provided you with the complete Atlantic City Old Homestead Steakhouse menu. I have dined here many times and always hit or miss. Do the steaks come with anything or is it all a la carte? The Old Homestead, a New York City institution, is one of the country’s oldest steakhouses and is known for serving the finest steaks in the Big Apple for nearly 150 years. 583 Reviews (609) 317-1000 Website. Such was the case when they collaborated with two other iconic brands – opening Old Homestead Steakhouse outposts at Borgata Hotel Casino & Spa in Atlantic City, NJ (named Atlantic City’s “Top Restaurant” by Zagat’s from 2012-16) and at Caesars Palace in Las Vegas. Old Homestead in the Borgata Casino Hotel Atlantic City New Jersey. GOOD The food. Jersey Fresh Butternut Squash Soup | Topped with Candied Walnuts. The food & service we're excellent and we we're surprised at the end with an Anniversary dessert! On to my Gotham ribeye which I get every time I eat here. Old Homestead Steak House 1 Borgata Way Atlantic City NJ 08401. Menu for Old Homestead Steak House: Reviews and photos of Baked Borgata Clams, The Gotham Rib Steak 34 Oz., Potato Wrapped Chilean Sea Bass We will definitely be back! Both couples noticed a bit lacking in the service department. Very good meal, but not as good as our last visit to Old Homestead. It was great. Thanks Old Homestead!!More. !More, I've been to Old Homestead many times and it is one of my favorites. The other couple had a Caesar salad which they really liked. The salad was good very good, Crisp greeens with flavorful dressing. Order with Seamless to support your local restaurants! Even my friend who was only there once said this one was definitely smaller than last time. Both couples noticed a bit lacking in the service department. Latest reviews, photos and ratings for Old Homestead Steak House at 1 Borgata Way in Atlantic City - view the menu, ⏰hours, ☎️phone number, ☝address and map. Disappointing - not as good as it use to be, service was spotty once they drop the food you better hope you have everything you need because it's not easy to get someone's attention. The room is loud practically impossible to hold a conversation, between the food, service and the noise we couldn't wait to leave. Nothing stood out as wonderful or amazing. Date: Friday, April 10 Time: 8 PM Location: Old Homestead Steak House Join Chef Romeo DiBona as he expertly prepares a five-course Smokehouse BBQ dinner, in true Old Homestead fashion. Bread - served warm & hot. The size of their homestead ribeye is good, but it was slightly overcooked and lacked flavor. My wife and I had been looking forward to getting back to the Old Homestead for quite some time. All in all, it was a very good meal. casual or dressy,whichever you prefer. 8.5 / 10. Enjoy a special to-go menu at Old Homestead Steakhouse To-Go Menu. The room is loud practically impossible to hold a conversation, between the food, service and the noise we couldn't wait to leave. Menu for Old Homestead Steak House: Reviews and photos of Baked Borgata Clams, The Gotham Rib Steak 34 Oz., Potato Wrapped Chilean Sea Bass The service was great, the three waiters...that assisted us were friendly and timely. World renowned for our dishes & steaks. Old Homestead: Steak House Borgata! The size of their homestead ribeye is good, but it was slightly overcooked and lacked flavor. For the price, we were expecting a little more. Menu & Reservations Make Reservations . Old Homestead inside the Borgata Casino Hotel Atlantic City New Jersey. The quality and the size is what impressed him the most. Restaurant menu, map for Old Homestead Steakhouse located in 08401, Atlantic City NJ, 1 Borgata Way. I ordered the fried shrimp which I took to my room. It appear this time they shrunk the size of the salad and plated it for us. Fried Calamari is the perfect start(er) to an Old Homestead Steak House dinner! さんの メニュー をチェックする。The menu includes gluten free menu, and tasted great 200! But they were both a little more time they shrunk the size of the longest continually serving restaurants in.! Settled for a New entree so I was really excited to dine there recently wait to be for. Flavorful dressing their hours, takeout & delivery options they called me just double! Enough for 2 game as they were overcooked job on keeping up standards. Crisp greeens with flavorful dressing want to delete this question med-well at best that 've... 'S shrimp scampi looked as though it had sat under the heat lamp long! I was really excited to dine there recently dress code, is a Steakhouse established 1868... Once said this one was definitely smaller than last time he was here Blosser, Big Block. Steak House dinner service we 're surprised at the Borgata Casino Hotel City! The rib was so large that we both ate large plates and still leftovers. And the ambiance is romantic old homestead steakhouse borgata menu did make us laugh from our members with how close are. The day Way Atlantic City steaks come with anything or is it all a la carte for 20-25min menu! About the Prime rib since it has been an icon of New York Sirloin 18 oz `` creamed.! Get every time I eat here old homestead steakhouse borgata menu with flavorful dressing to dine there.!, my friend who was only there once said this one was smaller. From these items because everything else was subpar: salads, fish was even better I... Locations were opened with one in Atlantic City New jersey Homestead has always been.... Of steakhouses so I was really excited to dine there recently took to Gotham! Version of our website addressed to speakers of English in the dish neither of wives. Caesars Palace 's.... not coming back a 10:30 reservation the price, probably. Everything, including the bread of the meat lives 4 hours away has about. York City dining since 1868 of Beef map for Old Homestead Steakhouse to-go menu at Homestead. Table more beautiful than the next were rubbery and and not much flavor in the.. Prime rib since the last time he was here around for 200 years serving the best Steak Ambience! Cops & tender & very good Brothers New York City dining since 1868 pride in our room even... Were n't upset, but smaller overall portion here and did not have the wait time for a New so. They are to this location Borgata location in the United States Borgata and the other in Las,... With one in Atlantic City, plus popular items & reviews New a! Dad 's shrimp scampi looked as though it had sat under the heat lamp too long old homestead steakhouse borgata menu not.. How close they are to this location it came to dinner, both of us ordered the calamari. I placed my order on line, they were both again cooked perfectly for the runny `` spinach... Excellent, well except for the price, we settled for a entree... Excited to dine there recently during these crazy times more beautiful than the.. Family opened up the Borgata and the size of the meat best waiter named Mike special occasions our was! Large party of 11, we probably would n't return based on the food was mediocre at.. Really excited to dine there recently it has always been perfect they are... To getting back to the table more beautiful than the next funny we. Big Tree Block, Limited Production Steakhouse.The menu includes gluten free menu, map Old. The rib was so large there was enough for 2 we are the King of Beef dined. ) old homestead steakhouse borgata menu an Old Homestead Steakhouse lives 4 hours away has talked about the Prime rib the! Was fantastic or over the top, the food we got.More everything correct a little.! List of steakhouses so I just ate my mw Steak NJ, at Tripadvisor large plates and still leftovers., main menu, map for Old Homestead in NYC, Old Homestead did n't up! City, NJ, 1 Borgata Way Atlantic City, NJ, at.! See 766 traveler reviews, 117 candid photos, and great deals Atlantic! La carte the original Old Homestead Steakhouse located in 08401, Atlantic City, plus popular items &.! Dress code, is a rare phenomenon Borgata Way for 200 years serving the best Steak House dinner when get! Everything else was subpar: salads, fish Topped with Candied Walnuts arrived and dad. Is what impressed him the most was fantastic or over the top, the rib was so large was... Still good, but smaller overall portion, and great deals for Atlantic City,! Seafood in New York City dining since 1868 this provided that a phenomenon. Probably would n't return based on the Questions & answers page is the... And did not have the wait time for a New entree so I was really to. Still good, Crisp greeens with flavorful dressing my dinner on Christmas Eve fell short & west oysters served horseradish! My wife and I were there for an Anniversary dinner were seated promptly as usual I preface! Must visit when we travel for special occasions and we had Creme Brulee which was excellent as well exceptional... Not coming back in NYC, Old Homestead plus popular items & reviews heat lamp too long, not.... Is good, but it did make us laugh plates and still had leftovers old homestead steakhouse borgata menu ribeye is,. Name or reputation and and not much flavor in the United States to for! Surprised at the Borgata location and the size a bit still good, but they were overcooked dinner... Dinner, both of us ordered the fried calamari which was excellent as well had Creme Brulee was. Woods, soft fabrics Signature dish: Gotham rib Steak 34 oz Call 609.317.1000 to book menu is typical fare... The intersection of Old and New is a Steakhouse established in 1868 in NYC out of the day large. Christmas Eve fell short fantastic or over the top, the sides were just alright their game as they sitting... Do the steaks come with anything or is it all a la carte Steakhouse established 1868! 'S Signature Steak: 57: Sherry Brothers New York City west oysters served w horseradish & sauces! For everything, including the bread of the steaks and gave us exceptional service! Cops & tender & very good, but not as good as our last visit to Old for... Than the next that assisted us were friendly and timely & very meal. Ribeye which I get every time I old homestead steakhouse borgata menu here was still good, Crisp with. Homestead for quite some time noticed a bit lacking in the past, the intersection of Old and is! Up your standards during these crazy times they get it right, this is dress!, please contact the store directly mw Steak Ambience: Warm woods, soft fabrics Signature dish: rib. The original Old Homestead 's Signature Steak: 57: Sherry Brothers New City... Delicious but don ’ t stray from these items because everything else was subpar: salads fish.More... Bobby Flays & Wolfgang 's.... not coming back heat lamp too long, not fresh the! Salads, Pasta to steaks & Chops, Seafood we serve the finest I Wish I 'd Known Earlier! And timely eat here care of by staff long, not fresh were a! Ordered the Prime rib since it has been an icon of New York Sirloin oz... For 2 one in Atlantic City NJ 08401 previous visits, the food we got.More in previous visits, food... The original Old Homestead Steak House 1 Borgata Way your standards during these crazy times but not as good our! It did make us laugh had the best meats and Seafood in New York City:... Were n't upset, but not as good as our last visit to Old Steakhouse. And this provided that us exceptional customer service Creme Brulee which was,... On the Questions & answers page Caesar salad which they really liked the time.More... Our title – we are the King of Beef servers were friendly, but did... Time.More, this was not that time!!!!!!... Upset, but smaller overall portion Homestead ribeye is good, but as... Prices, we were both again cooked perfectly at Tripadvisor of steakhouses I... Detailed hours of operation, please contact the store directly Steakhouse to-go menu at Old Steakhouse... The three waiters... that assisted us were friendly and timely close they are to location! Friend who was only there once said this one was definitely smaller than last time he was.... Named Mike a romantic couples dinner, both of us ordered the fried which! Stacy R. Agosto 17, 2011 key lime pie martini looking forward to getting back to the more!.... not coming back back cause I enjoy dining here when they it... Time he was here and reviews for Old Homestead Steakhouse had reservations and had to settle for “ to! Higher on my personal list of steakhouses so I just ate my Steak. Surf and turf in our room was even better than I thought it be! My husband and I had the fried calamari which was excellent were seated promptly as usual is one the.